The first goody bags I made for kids was last year when my daughter turned four. I asked her preschool for ideas on what I should do. She said that all goody bags have to be the same. They also should have a couple of yummy treats. Kids like the little toys but they love candy. It's important to also ask about allergies. I bought toys from the dollar store and Oriental Trading. The candy type goodies were from the grocery. Fruit chews, suckers, hard candy and nut free treats are fun.
I glued on paper from DCWV. The boy goody bags had DCWV Nautical stack and the girls paper was a floral stack. I used up old ribbon so the ribbon closures were different on the girls bags. No complaints. Yay!